10 Great Movies That Would’ve Been Even Better Novels
Link copied to clipboardSign in to your Collider account
Generate a summary of this story
Rather than serving up action and straightforward plots, some movies explore inner lives, abstract ideas, and emotional atmospheres. In this regard, they’re almost more like introspective literature than traditional cinema. With this in mind, this list looks at some films that already feel like novels and might’ve been even stronger if expanded into an actual book.
For all their cinematic power, the following titles might’ve soared even higher in literary form. Whether they’re fragmented, surreal, or quietly introspective, they all lend themselves to narration, stream of consciousness, and complex ideas. As movies, they might’ve been appreciated but slightly misunderstood; however, as novels, their true potential might’ve actually been realized.
10‘The Fountain’ (2006)
Directed by Darren Aronofsky
“Death is the road to awe.” The Fountain, Darren Aronofsky‘s famously trippy romantic epic, is a film that spans a millennium, jumps between timelines, and weaves together science fiction, myth, and raw grief. It’s stunning to look at, but its emotional core is often buried beneath abstraction. Many people disliked it for this reason, and it was a colossal box office bomb. That said, it boasts a lot of intriguing ideas, explaining why it’s since become something of a cult film.
As a novel, it could’ve slowed down, freed from the constraints of a feature-length runtime. Let its characters breathe and give readers the time to fully unpack its cosmic metaphors and spiritual yearning. Its fragmented narrative would thrive on the page, where interior monologue could deepen the beauty and the heartbreak. Hugh Jackman and Rachel Weisz are excellent, but in print, their reincarnated identities could be more richly fleshed out.
The Fountain
PG-13
Documentary
Sci-Fi
9.0/10Release DateNovember 22, 2006
Expand
9‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind’ (2004)
Directed by Michel Gondry
“Blessed are the forgetful, for they get the better even of their blunders.” Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is already a great movie, easily one of the most emotionally intelligent science fiction films ever made. Still, its nonlinear structure and dreamlike transitions cry out for literary treatment. This story is about memory, love, and self-erasure, all themes that could thrive even more deeply in the format of a stream-of-consciousness novel. On the page, the boundaries between memory and reality could blur more subtly, not to mention more painfully.
Charlie Kaufman’s screenplay already feels like prose at times: looping, poetic, deeply personal. There are probably earlier drafts of the script with way more material and even deeper depths. In a novel, Joel’s (Jim Carrey) repression and Clementine’s (Kate Winslet) volatility might take on new textures. A book would also allow readers to flip back and forth between past and present, erased memories and raw emotions.
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
R
Sci-Fi
8.3/10Release DateMarch 19, 2004
Expand
8‘A Ghost Story’ (2017)
Directed by David Lowery
“What is it you’re trying to hold on to?” A Ghost Story is minimalist, meditative, and achingly slow, less about narrative and more about feeling, specifically the feeling of being left behind. A man (Casey Affleck) dies, becomes a ghost under a white sheet, and watches time pass. He can neither move on to the next world nor fully participate in this one. There’s barely any dialogue, no plot twists, but there’s so much soul (*ba dum tss*). That soul would come through even more clearly in literary form.
As a novel, the ghost’s perspective could be expanded into something even more painfully rich, detached, wordless, and deeply observant. The film’s iconic pie-eating scene, which stretches in silence, would become an incredible interior monologue. And the exploration of time, particularly its vastness and its indifference, would find a natural home in prose. A Ghost Story already lingers like a half-remembered dream; as a book, it might be twice as devastating.
A Ghost Story
R
Documentary
9.0/10Release DateApril 24, 2017
Expand
7‘Enemy’ (2013)
Directed by Denis Villeneuve
“Chaos is order yet undeciphered.” A quiet professor (Jake Gyllenhaal) stumbles upon an actor who looks exactly like him, and things only get weirder from there, culminating in a brilliantly creepy final scene. Gyllenhaal plays both roles with eerie restraint, but the film offers little clarity, deliberately refusing to untangle its web of symbols and doppelgängers. Its elliptical nature is part of what makes it so haunting, but it also leaves viewers stranded in ambiguity. As a result, the movie was pretty divisive: some see it as a masterpiece, others as waffle.
A book version could resolve some of these tensions by immersing us in the protagonist’s inner fragmentation even more. We could explore his internal monologue and sink deeper into the existential implications of confronting another self. The spider imagery, the blurring of dreams and reality, the cryptic climax, all of it would gain new dimensions in prose, where metaphor and stream-of-consciousness flourish. It could’ve been classic of surreal literature.
Enemy
R
Mystery
DramaThrillerRelease DateFebruary 6, 2014Runtime91 MinutesDirectorDenis Villeneuve
Expand
6‘Synecdoche, New York’ (2008)
Directed by Charlie Kaufman
“There are nearly thirteen million people in the world. None of those people is an extra.” Charlie Kaufman strikes again. Synecdoche, New York might be the most literary movie never adapted from a book. It’s dense, ambitious, and almost punishing in its emotional depth. Philip Seymour Hoffman plays Caden Cotard, a playwright whose magnum opus, a sprawling life-size replica of New York, turns into a decades-long maze of metaphysical self-destruction. The deeper Caden goes, the more life and art blur.
It is the definition of meta: People play people who are playing people, time becomes fluid, and the boundaries of identity collapse. As a novel, this would be the ultimate postmodern tragedy. Caden’s voice could unravel in footnotes, shifting narration, or disintegrating grammar. We could spend entire chapters in one rehearsal or inside one crisis of faith. Fiction would give room to expand on his inner anxieties, obsession with death, and longing for connection.
Synecdoche, New York
R
DocumentaryRelease DateOctober 24, 2008Runtime124 minutesDirectorCharlie Kaufman
Expand
5‘The Double Life of Veronique’ (1991)
Directed by Krzysztof Kieślowski
“Each of us is alone.” The Double Life of Veronique is a poetic, impressionistic film by Polish master Krzysztof Kieślowski. It tells the story of two women, Weronika in Poland and Véronique in France (both played by Irène Jacob), who never meet, yet share a mysterious emotional bond. They are doubles in spirit, in voice, even in fate. One dies young, and the other, somehow, feels the loss. The film is sparse on plot but rich with visual metaphor and musicality, exactly like a literary novel.
Once again, prose would allow readers to slip inside the consciousness of both women: their daily lives, emotional flinches, and intuitive decisions could be rendered in vivid internal detail. The symbolic could become emotional, and the metaphysical could become even more tragic and stirring. The Double Life of Veronique is already a whisper of a masterpiece. A book would lean into the complexity even harder.
The Double Life of Véronique
R
DramaRelease DateMay 15, 1991Runtime98 minutesDirectorKrzysztof Kieślowski
Expand
4‘The Tree of Life’ (2011)
Directed by Terrence Malick
“Mother. Father. Always you wrestle inside me.” The Tree of Life is part family memoir, part cosmic opera. It shifts between intimate domestic scenes in 1950s Texas and the vast birth of the universe. There are scenes of parents fighting alongside shots of literal velociraptors. It’s a movie that doesn’t explain itself. Instead, it washes over you, a wave of memory fragments, whispered voiceovers, and impressionistic visuals. Heck, even Sean Penn said he didn’t really understand it, and he acts in the dang thing.
In prose, Jack’s (Penn) voice could drift across decades and galaxies, exploring the philosophical weight of grief, guilt, beauty, and belief. The timeline might remain nonlinear, but with even more room for spiritual and emotional rumination. Whole chapters could be devoted to a single moment, a single question, a single feeling. The Tree of Life is already a meditation; an author could dig even deeper with it.
The Tree of Life
pg-13
DramaRelease DateNovember 17, 2011Runtime138minutesDirectorTerrence Malick
Expand
3‘Columbus’ (2017)
Directed by Kogonada
“Are we losing interest in everyday life?” Columbus is a quiet film about architecture, attention, and the slow ache of feeling stuck. It centers on two strangers—Casey (Haley Lu Richardson), a young woman tethered to her ailing mother, and Jin (John Cho), an architect whose father is in a coma—who form a delicate connection as they walk and talk in Columbus, Indiana. There’s no grand climax, no dramatic revelation, and certainly no action. Just human observation, spatial stillness, and the pain of lives paused.
A book version would get even more intimate in its character study. Casey’s internal conflict, her torn loyalty between staying and growing, could be richly explored, as could Jin’s lingering resentment. In other words, a novel would linger where the movie just glances. The material here is inherently literary rather than cinematic, so subtle you almost miss it: the space between moments, the unsaid things, the emotional weight of the everyday.
Columbus
Unrated
DramaRelease DateAugust 4, 2017Runtime104 MinutesDirectorKogonada
Expand
2‘Waking Life’ (2001)
Directed by Richard Linklater
“Dream is destiny.” Waking Life is less a movie than a moving philosophical sketchbook. Rotoscoped animation overlays real-world footage as an unnamed dreamer (Wiley Wiggins) drifts through conversations about free will, time, existentialism, and the nature of reality. There’s no plot, just wandering minds and fluid visuals. It’s the movie version of a late-night conversation with smart friends. Some find it pretentious, others consider it profound, but pretty much everyone agrees it was a bold, creative gamble.
Waking Life is a fantastically unique movie that would probably be even more thought-provoking as a novel. Without the visual gimmickry, the book version might deliver deeper into the ideas themselves, layering essayistic passages with dream fragments, fictional debates, and surreal transitions. The dream logic could expand, allowing for richer introspection and more emotional grounding. We’d lose the phenomenal acting but get double the mind-expanding weirdness. It would be like a crash course in philosophy compressed into a few hundred vibrantly written pages.
Waking Life
R
AnimationDramaFantasyRelease DateOctober 19, 2001Runtime101 minutesDirectorRichard Linklater
Expand
1‘Coherence’ (2013)
Directed by James Ward Byrkit
“You guys have been acting pretty strange tonight.” Coherence is a lo-fi sci-fi thriller about eight dinner guests who discover that a passing comet has fractured reality. Paranoia sets in as the power flickers and timelines twist. Characters doubt who they are, what they’ve done, and which version of their lives they’re even in. It’s a pulpy premise, but one tightly written, almost entirely improvised, and shot on a shoestring budget. Still, despite the modest resources at its disposal, the movie is tenser than many blockbusters.
Coherence is already an underrated sci-fi cult gem. In literary form, it might’ve become the next Great (Mind-bending) American Novel. The shifting realities would be less disorienting in prose, where internal narration could guide the reader through each character’s dread. A book version could also more complexly explore the film’s big-brain ideas, particularly the existential horror of losing your singular self, of becoming one possibility among dozens. Subtle variations in memory, behavior, or emotion could be magnified.
